About 130 to 125 million years ago, a slender plant grew in shallow lakes in what is now Spain. It is among the oldest flowering plants known from fossils. That puts it in the same huge group as roses, oaks and grasses, but it looked nothing like them. It had no petals and no nectar, and scientists think it spent its whole life under water.

Its fossils were first found in fine limestone in the Spanish Pyrenees more than 100 years ago. For a long time, nobody could agree on what they were. Some scientists thought they were a liverwort, a horsetail or a conifer. Then in 2015, a team studied more than 1,000 specimens. They dissolved the rock with acid and looked at the plant's very thin outer skin under microscopes.

The clue was in the fruit. Each tiny fruit was closed except for a small pore, and it held one seed hanging upside down inside. A seed wrapped inside a fruit like this is a mark of flowering plants. The fruits came in pairs.

The fossils show thin, bendy stems, and not a single root among all those shoots. From this, scientists think it drifted or grew without roots under water. Its flowers were plain, and each was either male or female. Its fruits had only a tiny pore, with no proper part for catching pollen. These clues suggest the water probably carried its pollen.

Two looks, one plant

It grew in two forms. One had long, narrow, needle-like leaves in opposite pairs. The other had spiralling branches covered in short, scale-like leaves.

A busy ancient lake

One of its fossil sites, Las Hoyas, was a shallow lake in a large inland wetland with a warm, subtropical climate. About 250 species are known from there, including early birds and a mammal whose fossil even kept traces of hair.

A race for 'oldest'

One of the scientists who studied it said it was about as old as, or older than, Archaefructus from China. That is another early water plant that also competes for the title of oldest flowering plant.

Next to it on the tree

Words used

Flowering plant
A plant that makes its seeds inside a closed fruit. Most plants alive today, from grasses to trees, are flowering plants.
Pollen
Tiny grains a plant makes that must reach another part of a plant so seeds can form.

What is still uncertain

  • The fossils are flattened pieces of shoots, fruits and seeds pressed into fine limestone. No whole plants have been found. Its colour, how it grew, whether it floated freely and how its pollen travelled are all worked out from clues, not seen directly.
  • Not everyone agrees it was a flowering plant. One researcher argued in 2011 that it belonged to a different group of seed plants and lived in coastal marshes. A 2022 review said the missing roots might only mean the fossils are incomplete.
  • A 2015 study placed it as the closest relative of coontail (Ceratophyllum), a living water plant. That link rests only on fossil features, so Lifetree places it directly under flowering plants. It is not in the Open Tree of Life.
  • It is among the oldest flowering plant fossils of a whole plant, but it is not certainly the oldest. Older fossil pollen from flowering plants is known.

Sources

Written with AI help and checked against these sources.