When tomatoes reached Europe in the 1500s, many people were wary of them. The problem was their family. Tomatoes belong to the nightshade family, which also includes deadly nightshade and mandrake, plants full of powerful poisons. To many people, a plant with relatives like that seemed risky to eat.

In 1597 an English herbalist, John Gerard, called tomatoes poisonous and 'of ranke and stinking savour' in a popular plant book. His view held in Britain and its North American colonies for about 200 years. In the early United States, people often grew tomatoes as pretty garden plants called 'love apples' before they ate them.

The fear was partly right. The leaves, stems and green, unripe fruit contain small amounts of natural poisons. The ripe fruit, though, is safe. Not everyone was worried. In 1544 an Italian writer, the first European known to describe tomatoes, said they could be cooked like an eggplant with salt, pepper and oil. People in Spain were eating them by the early 1600s, and a cookbook with tomato recipes came out in Naples in 1692.

The Spanish brought tomatoes over from the Americas. The tomato's wild ancestor grows in western South America. On the tree, the potato is a close cousin, and the chili pepper is a more distant relative in the same family.

A fruit to botanists, a vegetable by law

To a botanist, a tomato is a berry. But in 1893 the US Supreme Court ruled that tomatoes count as vegetables for import taxes, going by the everyday meaning of the word.

Shake it out

Tomato flowers make no nectar and keep their pollen locked inside. Bees such as bumblebees grab the flower and vibrate it very fast to shake the pollen loose. This is called buzz pollination.

An Aztec name

The word 'tomato' comes from the Spanish 'tomate'. That word comes from 'tomatl' in Nahuatl, the language of the Aztecs.

Next to it on the tree

Words used

Berry
To a botanist, a fleshy fruit with its seeds inside and no hard stone. Tomatoes count as berries, and so do grapes.
Buzz pollination
When a bee shakes a flower very fast so that the pollen falls out.

What is still uncertain

  • Some writers say acidic tomatoes pulled lead out of pewter plates and made rich diners sick, which fed the fear. Experts doubt this, because the amount of lead released would be tiny. Fear of the tomato's poisonous relatives is a more likely cause.
  • Some say the Italian herbalist who first wrote about tomatoes in Europe thought they were dangerous because of their family. But his 1544 book described cooking them, so his views are unclear.
  • Experts still debate where the tomato was first domesticated, in western South America or in Mexico and Central America. The timing is uncertain too, at roughly 7,000 years ago.
  • One major 2025 study suggests the potato began about 9 million years ago, when an ancestor of the tomato crossed with another plant. The idea is still new.

Sources

Written with AI help and checked against these sources.