About 365 to 359 million years ago, long before the dinosaurs, this plant made some of the very first seeds we know of. There were no cones, fruits or flowers. Each seed sat in a little open cup, shaped like a tulip made of slender fingers. One cup held four tiny seeds, each only a few millimetres long, tucked among sixteen thin, finger-like tips.

From a distance it looked like a fern. Its fronds grew in a spiral up a single stem with no branches, and they carried frilly, finely divided leaflets. But it was not a fern. It sat on the seed plant side of the family, so it was more closely related to conifers and flowering plants than to ferns.

Its fossils are broken pieces, mostly small seed-bearing shoots, but they are well preserved. They show the cups and seeds in fine detail. Some fronds carried small pollen-making parts instead of cups. Computer models suggest the cups slowed the passing air and caught pollen blowing on the wind, but the fossils cannot show this directly.

Seeds were a big step. Later, they helped plants spread into places that had been too hard to live in, and seed plants went on to fill the great coal-age forests.

Named after a town

Joseph Schwietering, a geologist, found the fossils in the late 1970s in rocks beside a highway, U.S. Route 33, near the town of Elkins, West Virginia. The plant is named after the town.

Not quite a modern seed

Its seed coat never fully closed over the inside of the seed to leave a proper little opening for pollen. Because of this, some botanists call its seeds 'preovules' instead of true modern ones.

There was an older forerunner

A plant called Runcaria, found in Belgium, lived about 20 million years earlier. It had most of the makings of a seed, but it had no solid seed coat.

Next to it on the tree

Words used

Preovule
An early, not-quite-finished kind of seed whose coat did not fully close at the tip.

What is still uncertain

  • Fossil evidence: it is known only from broken but well-preserved shoots, seed cups and stems. Its full height, colour, exact habitat and how it was pollinated are inferred. The idea of wind pollination rests only on computer airflow models.
  • Where exactly it sits on the tree is still being worked out. Here it is placed just outside the group that includes all living seed plants. A 2025 study put it at the very base of the seed plants, together with a Chinese early seed plant. It is not listed in the Open Tree of Life.
  • Sources disagree on whether it is the oldest known seed plant in the world or only in North America. Other seeds of similar age are known from elsewhere in North America, from Europe and from China.
  • Scientists still debate where the seed cup and seed coat came from. One idea is that they formed from shrunken, joined-up branches.

Sources

Written with AI help and checked against these sources.